@itsbreabird: Replying to @jaybullchild4 why did samwise gamgee and bilbo baggins also get to sail west in the lord of the rings? ps. all paid subscriptions to my tolkien substack are 30% off but only until july 18th! #samwisegamgee #bilbobaggins #lordoftherings #thelordoftherings #tolkientiktok #jrrtolkien
Do you think Sméagol would have been allowed to go West as well, if he had chosen good in the end?
2025-07-15 00:35:52
9
green beard :
didnt Sam stay
2025-07-15 00:34:00
0
læzydæz :
its important to remind ourselves that its the lands that are undying, not the souls chosen to go there. froto died. bilbo died. (I learned that from you, btw - thank you for posting such rich content 🫶)
2025-07-15 00:45:32
3
Telocvovim :
If they let Gimli in, basically they're gonna let anybody in if he's got enough social clout.
2025-07-15 03:46:57
0
Jerry Burke :
I suppose having to throw our smart phones into the fires of Mount Doom, and give up TikTok forever, would be the closest we mere mortals would have to losing The One Ring ☹️
2025-07-15 05:12:14
0
dior_aranel :
If Frodo had succeeded without Gollum dying, would Gollum have been allowed to go to the West?
2025-07-15 06:44:07
0
Justin Petrie :
Interesting
2025-07-15 04:00:49
0
celebreabird :
ps. all paid subscriptions to my tolkien substack are 30% off but only until july 18th! That space is where I’ll be hosting my fifth annual read-through of LOTR this September. Hope to see you there!
2025-07-15 00:24:54
1
To see more videos from user @itsbreabird, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.