emily | neuroscientist 🧠
Region: US
Sunday 10 November 2024 02:21:10 GMT
1201188
81090
3912
7229
Music
Download
Comments
webnerd :
Frequency is still there though - nobody to hear it but it exists
2024-11-10 02:36:05
7841
s1mon_39 :
Sorry, but explaining how a human perceives sound doesn’t negate sound itself. The answer is yes, the tree does make a sound, just not one that is heard by a human.
2024-11-10 11:27:02
1811
rooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo :
This argument only exists because people can’t comprehend things they can’t see
2025-07-26 20:41:00
0
Mo :
When your partner cheats on you and you weren’t there, did it really happen?
2024-11-10 13:01:26
3789
Tattooed Papi :
Sound exists without human beings. Sound exists by virtue of relativity. We just have the tools to identify and interact with sound. But the falling tree definitely makes a sound with or without us
2024-11-10 16:11:17
74
Spectator :
Inganekwane
2024-11-10 16:07:08
125
𝕊𝕞𝕚𝕝𝕖 😊 🇿🇦 :
The tree doesn't exist because there is no one to see it.
2024-11-10 07:52:30
1126
Blue :
Nope. That’s like saying everything beyond human perception doesn’t exist, which is wrong. Whales, dogs, etc can perceive sounds humans aren’t able to
2024-11-10 05:42:17
529
royroberts673 :
Well, yes, I would say every animal near there would hear it so the answer would be absolutely it still makes the sound. It’s just if no humans there to hear it. Who cares the sound is still made the animals here do they not?
2025-07-28 05:26:57
0
Laura Quinn :
if a tree falls in the forest it falls!
2025-05-26 01:19:40
1
Jaazi :
You mean if a sound recorder is kept in the forest, it will record nothing?
2024-11-10 08:22:27
88
beep beep :
The answer is yes, it produces sound. Your ear is not a measure of anything.
2024-11-10 14:17:33
131
Dan :
Yes. Makes a sound.
2024-11-10 06:13:58
68
Drivers Nightmare :
it makes a sound but not an ear to hear
2024-11-10 08:50:45
76
Dendiny :
speaking literally: yes it does, it's not asking about perception it's asking about action tree falling = consequence making a sound. Speaking philosophicaly : yes your actions matter when none watch
2024-11-10 06:50:02
40
Snedrik :
Are you OK?! 😳😂 Greetings from the Norwegian woods 🇳🇴
2024-11-10 06:17:00
83
Stanley :
It makes a sound, yes. Obviously.
2024-11-10 09:14:18
143
𝗦𝗞𝗨𝗧𝗟𝗘 :
Dolphins haven't seen camels so do camels exist?
2024-12-24 07:30:34
6
Kresta... :
The answer is yes, there are animals there & they'd hear it. Just because "nobody" as in human is there to hear it is immaterial.
2024-11-10 11:42:03
42
shoegum :
is the wall still behind me when im not looking? 💀
2024-11-10 07:24:17
2739
Brandon :
Absence of receiver is not absence of sender
2024-11-10 20:53:55
1509
Juliascookiejar :
But there are still sound waves coming off the tree
2025-02-09 14:48:46
0
I :
Just because no one hears the tree fall doesn’t mean it didn’t make a sound. Sound waves still exist whether or not there’s someone to interpret them. Our senses help us perceive reality —
2024-11-10 19:44:42
25
Mr.Ur.lol :
is this what they teach in America?
2024-11-10 23:33:37
45
SageG1rl :
Yes animals would have heard it and bugs
2024-11-10 18:27:41
72
To see more videos from user @emonthebrain, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.
