Denzel_Greene
Region: US
Monday 20 January 2025 17:12:56 GMT
84934
11322
1324
431
Music
Download
Comments
John Abbott :
Asking why the Holdo Manuever wasn't a more common thing is like asking why Kamikaze pilots aren't common irl.
2025-01-20 19:00:36
1259
Leapster3 :
I must be a fool because when I watched the movie the only thought in my brain was.... "Damn. That was AWESOME!"
2025-01-20 18:40:32
1090
shadowrunner429 :
“Why did no one think of it before?” is a baffling question to me. It’s like, I don’t know… maybe for the same reason *you* never thought of it before; somebody has to be the first.
2025-03-10 21:33:44
1
motherfucjer :
Not to mention the absolute truth of movie making: it was cool as hell
2025-01-20 18:09:14
440
ethereal :
Makes much more sense now but why didn’t the CIS use this tactic? If the CIS was gonna lose why wouldn’t they at least try? If you just need to be the correct distance wouldn’t a tactical droid be able to calculate it? They r going to abandon the droids anyway why not just do a Hail Mary? You risk nothing strategically and have everything to gain
2025-06-24 15:02:13
0
spiderwolve :
You know they actually demonstrated ships smacking off of Vader's SD in Rogue one who were about to hyper but didn't get up to speed.
2025-01-21 02:29:02
144
PsychoticPunk :
Also, if your read the High Republic books, it's very clear why having a damaged ship in hyperspace (whether it got there before or after taking damage) is severely dangerous, almost world ending.
2025-01-20 20:13:26
58
Bowen Underwood :
I honestly don't hate the sequel trilogy. my only complaint is I feel like we could have avoided the Po mutiny and Finn side adventure, if Holdo even so much as hinted as having a plan.
2025-03-10 20:51:27
1
David N. :
Great explanation! The Last Jedi is still my favorite film of the Sequel Trilogy. Definitely did not deserve the flack that it got. Especially compared to Rise of Skywalker.
2025-01-20 17:34:27
82
Robot Lizard Wizard :
people forgetting that the great hyperspace disaster is a thing also everything bro said is correct, it's like lining up a nuke at close range, low chance you'll pull it off and it's a great manoeuvre
2025-02-03 12:06:08
21
Randomly Generated Name :
I always saw the Holdo maneuver was a war crime move so no one did it. Although I feel like Chopper attempted thos or did it once before
2025-01-20 19:22:54
245
xanth79_Ez8 :
this is why they have astronavigational charts. in kotor 2 they mention that AN charts, especially in places where there's a lot of small bits like mining places or asteroid belts, are constantly 1/?
2025-01-21 21:03:24
0
thatmantaz🇦🇺🇨🇦🇬🇧 :
The problem with the Holdo maneuver is the existence of probe droids. Probe droids pods are hyperspace capable, so we know how small the lower bound is. Now you say that the shields are necessary for this to do enough damage, but small objects with enough momentum will do tremendous damage because physics, so there is absolutely no reason that capital ships wouldn't be hurling SWARMS of small projectiles at each other equipped with cheap hyperdrives, quantity being a quality all it's own after all.
2025-01-21 04:13:21
20
DRSMaximus :
Not to mention that this took place thirty or so years past the other movies. Maybe some new tech advance in hyperspace jumping also left this as a possibility
2025-01-21 22:37:14
0
UltimateOTP :
also it's almost like they didn't think to do it is the FX were good enough to do do it... ILM figured out how to create 3D in new hope but Lucas didn't like the look at the time
2025-01-21 10:21:58
0
Zonix_9 :
my fav pilot would probably be the freemakers and of course my fav ship is the arrow head
2025-05-17 13:31:45
0
RandyB :
So now I have in my mind that Holdo once had a tipsy bar conversation with a friend about if this was possible and was roundly argued down. In this moment she saw her chance to have the best
2025-03-12 03:13:12
0
Gizmo :
I think the main problem with this is no one thought of doing this before like people LOVE making weapons out of things and it's just unrealistic that no one in that universe though-
2025-03-10 04:53:36
1
The Ash King :
I agree that your argument explains why the heroes don't do this but is there a need for a death star if the bad guys could do this maneuver to planetary cities? the empire doesn't care about 1/2
2025-03-02 01:24:49
0
Manateeman2004 :
Why not just stick thrusters on an asteroid, turn of the failsafes, have a crew of droids to do rapid calculations and add some shields for damage? May not be easy but the empire built 2 death stars.
2025-01-21 23:57:39
8
Shifting Phase :
mybonly issue with Haldo is that she did what A LOT of poor leaders do and fail to inform her crew of NESSISARY info, they didn't need the whole plan, but enough to not go rouge and risk the bigger
2025-03-05 02:01:17
1
BearDownBaby :
Holdo maneuver was the coolest moment outside the OG Trilogy.
2025-01-20 17:20:22
129
Reynauld Primus :
your point about jumping too close won't do damage. don't we see that in Rogue One when Vaders Star Destroyer shows up? I might be wrong but I remember a scene where Rebels are fleeing and some jump-
2025-02-18 17:17:11
0
J B63949 :
Always mad respect for Holdo going full Worf. "Perhaps today IS a good day to die."
2025-02-22 22:41:13
0
To see more videos from user @denzel_greene, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.
