🇨🇦Marcus Territory🇨🇦
Region: CA
Friday 23 May 2025 19:36:20 GMT
406806
56178
1055
8271
Music
Download
Comments
The Gay Elk System :
counterpoint: the ring obviously possesses free will, and can make complex decisions, and thus Is A Sentiant Being, and thus Cannot Be Property
2025-05-23 20:46:28
3885
Spencer Brownlee :
I don’t think the crown has authority over Mordor. British Empire: Hold my ale
2025-05-23 20:44:55
1822
Autumn Song :
But what if the property (facts) remained lost after a certain king's death and was found by a... crazy gollem. As it's been lost for millenniums... is it finders-keepers now?
2025-07-11 17:04:39
0
Rob Meyers :
“Tolkien notoriously lacked an eye for detail” is truly my favourite part of this.
2025-05-24 02:27:02
1977
🇨🇦Marcus Territory🇨🇦 :
Also I cut a whole section of this script in re: Celebrimbor potentially having IP rights in the ring’s design. Short answer: he’s probably got nothing, and it wouldn’t interfere with the final claim anyway.
2025-05-23 20:10:31
667
Spencer :
all good, but, Aragorn (the "rightful" owner) is offered the Ring but REFUSES it. therefore the current possessor, Frodo, becomes the rightful owner
2025-05-24 05:17:29
387
othertimbo :
No, I DEMAND a explanation of how Gollum has the legal right to the ring. (Absolutely loved this video thank you)
2025-05-23 20:27:06
514
eldritchmilkshake :
Sméagol and Aragorn fighting for ownership of the One Ring in a Judge Judy style sure would be really funny
2025-05-24 08:40:03
273
Liz🦎 :
I am still hung up on “Tolkien being notoriously bad at giving details” you know how to get engagement my friend 🤣🤣 I almost wrote a dissertation 🤣🤣
2025-05-31 12:36:10
3
Newyguy4shaw :
so if aragorn had the legal right to the ring and then frodo tried to give the ring back to him and it was declined by aragorn then is that title transfered to frodo at aragorn's behest?
2025-05-24 02:11:15
325
CptCorgums :
Considering the ring was a crucial part of a war, and taken by a king, I think it would less fall under individual property laws and more likely under an international treatise for reparations. Meaning the ring belongs to the crown. So still Aragorn…
2025-05-23 23:38:53
29
albertparent :
Gollum posessed the ring for hundreds of years with no claims made against him. Are there magical artifact squatters rights?
2025-05-24 01:31:14
85
Mechete :
You should read the council of Elrond in Fellowship. This is when Aragorn is revealed to Frodo as Isildur’s heir, and Frodo exclaims “Then it’s your ring and not mine at all!” So, your assessment isn’t far off. Aragorn responds that it doesn’t belong to either him or Frodo, but asks that he continue to carry it for a while.
2025-05-23 23:45:40
17
🍉Celebrían 🏳️🌈 :
I waited until the end. I feel like Don Marshall would be proud
2025-05-24 00:05:28
202
Mike Maurer he him his. Nerd :
Sméagol was finder keeper after the dude lost it. Bilbo was the finder keeper when gollum lost it. Bilbo gave it to Frodo. So it’s Frodo’s ducking ring. Finders keepers
2025-05-23 23:32:33
4
Waveone84 :
America might have jurisdiction over Mordor
2025-06-18 14:28:31
1
blarson9 :
Technically though, Sauron is still “alive” so is it not still his? Then Frodo, very rudely, bring the ring back to Sauron’s house and destroys it in the same fire that Sauron created it in which does in fact kill Sauron. So, Frodo both destroys Sauron’s property and murders him at the same time.
2025-05-23 20:19:38
19
Max :
Wait, Sauron was a mayar, so as Glendalf and Saruman(and Barlog), so they are, basically, brothers. Doesn't it mean, that they should inherit the ring?
2025-05-23 20:13:00
36
Marc-Antoine 🇨🇦 :
I choked on my drink at "Tolkien notoriously packed an eye for detail"
2025-05-23 23:55:34
78
Jacob :
Pretty sure it’s post Malone
2025-05-23 22:45:19
60
Jay Strider :
But herein lies the problem: Sauron didn’t die. He was bested in battle and hid physical form lost for a time, but he didn’t die.
2025-05-23 20:31:51
286
Susie :
Before I go google what “porphyrogeniture” means, I wanna guess. It means your purpleist child inherits it.
2025-05-23 21:39:26
44
Betsy Hodge :
Technically though wouldn’t “The Crown” in question over Mordor? And since that land was conquered by an alliance of several nations the land and…
2025-05-28 20:29:14
0
neins 🏳️🌈⃤ 🇵🇸 :
serious question: you can't split a ring in two. If there are two sons, how would this be handled?
2025-05-24 13:11:06
0
Kat_the_Pirate_Queen on Ao3 :
I could never be a lawyer with the way I snorted at "in testate"
2025-05-24 06:50:02
8
To see more videos from user @marcusterritory, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.
