I think this conversation is more about Julie James vs Sidney Prescott rather than JLH and Neve Campbell. JLH has actually worked really consistently and is well known for roles outside of IKWYDLS. Neve is really only known for scream (and I think she’s fine with that. She’s not about that Hollywood hustle, she lives in France for a reason). BUT Sidney is THAT girl. She is one of the most iconic final girls of all time. Julie on the other hand, got outshone in both of her movies (by Helen and Carla) and people wish SMG had been the final girl instead. Helen has way more fans than JJ. Not JLH’s fault, JJ is just a weakly written character as you pointed out. And so this to me is about the legacy of their final girls and not the quality of their careers. Both have had fulfilling careers and have done well for themselves.
2025-07-30 16:31:46
15
Sam Mish :
I do think Jennifer has had a better career than Neve. Post 2000s Neve is only known for Scream. Jennifer has had long running tv shows, multiple.
2025-07-30 15:07:03
42
Demurphy997 :
This is the first time I’m hearing someone say they think Neve Campbell is more successful than JLH.
2025-07-31 04:03:21
3
likeagreektragedy :
100% agree about the Julie James character assassination. ISKWYDLS killed the whole entire foundation of Julie James. You can not tell me that that is the same character who used logic, reason, and research to figure out who The Fisherman was only to come back for a sequel and become giddy when "Mark in the Morning" calls her phone line SECONDS after she chides Karla for Tyrell calling because her number is unlisted
2025-07-30 19:12:23
2
pumpkinkingla :
Jennifer also also turned down a lot of horror roles in the 90s/2000s because she didn’t want to be typed cast.
2025-07-30 18:03:00
0
SerpentThouArtLoose🇵🇸🇭🇹 :
What is neve in post scream trilogy but a rock movie and Lincoln lawyer.
2025-07-31 23:33:12
0
BrinaBeenIt :
Wellll Ghost whisperer, 911, The client list, she had the most consistent career
2025-07-30 16:25:46
36
ShelbyUrista :
What do you mean the same type a career. She has had multiple long running tv shows…..this is actually where the money is at. I can’t think of Neve Campbell really outside of the scream franchise….Hewitt is versatile and has consistently worked. Not even a fan but just having knowledge of media this is obvious.
2025-07-30 20:23:33
1
McMillanKid :
I liked that they gave the legacy characters something to do and some development
2025-07-31 02:13:45
0
dop3ritrean :
I enjoyed the movie but I couldn’t done without the twist.
2025-07-30 01:34:17
0
signiff :
IKWYDLS 2025 sort of washed Scream 5 idc. Genuinely one of, if not THEE, best "requel" we've gotten since Halloween started the era of.
2025-07-30 15:56:50
1
Asia.B :
IKWYDLS never felt like a true franchise like Scream. Both JLH and Neve were in Party of Five, but JLH built a strong TV career, while Neve stayed known for Party of Five, The Craft, Scream, and more. It’s cool how they both found their own paths in Hollywood. I wouldn’t really compare them, same with SMG.
2025-07-30 21:22:51
0
nonbinarypisces :
I haven't seen it yet but now I wanna go back and familiarize myself with them before I do. But from seeing her other work there was no way Jennifer would allow herself to go back and be that kind of role. Having seen her on Criminal Minds and 911. So I'm glad as for you and other fans this bad writing was rectified.
2025-07-29 21:31:14
9
Ship :
She’s worked more consistently than Neve, she just doesn’t receive as much fanfare.
2025-07-31 00:11:39
6
spellingfilms :
I would actually argue that Jennifer and has had a more successful career
2025-07-30 10:02:58
6
vincent :
Julie James was never that interesting from the start
2025-07-30 10:22:12
1
Liv :
What are you even talking about? Jennifer’s career is way more successful than neve. 😂
2025-07-31 14:22:54
1
To see more videos from user @hennyondatok, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.