YouTube: Ategekashelf
Region: US
Monday 04 August 2025 05:37:56 GMT
53988
6966
89
54
Music
Download
Comments
elias :
just because a life form isn’t perceiving something doesn’t mean it’s not happening
2025-08-04 21:00:08
1297
ellie :
but shes right if a tree falls around nobody it still makes sound waves that doesnt js stop existing if nobody's there
2025-08-04 11:27:26
712
angie :
realistically there will always be SOMETHING to hear the tree falling. humans are not the only animal that can hear
2025-08-05 15:46:08
237
Ixchel :
why
2025-08-04 09:27:19
14
aubergenaa✨ :
Wait so what are your thoughts on it
2025-08-04 23:17:34
5
Marimar🌊🐚🥥 :
Philosophy changes due to the viewer and the philosopher it’s not “wrong”. Philosophy is an art it should be treated as is.
2025-08-04 11:22:00
93
🪷 :
It’s about the fact that she feels unseen in her own being, she’s desperately affirming her value despite feeling unseen by society and her peers like ugh it has nothing to do with the philosophical argument of sound not being perceived without other people 🤫
2025-08-06 04:26:54
38
poolaebear :
while the sound waves are still reflecting sound itself is the perception of sound waves and if theres no one to perceive the sound then the sound doesnt exist. but in the song she was making speaking more figuratively so it doesnt really matter
2025-08-05 03:16:09
24
jan ! :
people who disagree w that line are doing it for attention im sorry
2025-09-09 19:31:33
22
☆Kaylyn☆ :
she's saying that even if no one realizes she struggling that doesnt mean she isn't -or that atleast how I interpret it
2025-08-06 07:28:08
54
★Wylan & Finnick's version🐌 :
I agree and disagree at the same time bc tbh there isn't an actual answer
2025-08-05 00:23:21
24
em 🫧 :
depends how you define ‘sound’… the waves alone or a human’s ‘actualisation’ of the waves - probably a question for a physicist
2025-08-05 17:52:38
60
🥶 :
Three dialogues between Hylas and Philonous type beat
2025-08-06 02:17:01
0
Laurenn!💋 :
It depend on which definition
2025-09-05 18:28:28
0
Mylittlesecretacc :
Is it still a sound if nothing was around to hear it?
2025-08-05 00:59:49
8
kennys_left_toe :
I love people debating philosophy I find it so interesting
2025-08-06 14:49:56
0
cow :
right right
2025-08-04 21:39:44
1
ppeanutties7 :
soemtimes i wonder if i existed in a vacuum where i can still see the world but the world can not see or interact w me if i would have i existed? for i have not caused even slight change to the world. does me perceiving the world mean that i have existed? or does something need to have even minuscule impact to have existed
2025-08-06 05:55:44
2
cia 🎧ྀི♪⋆.✮ :
i change my mind on this topic everytimeee, i cannot stick with a solid answer
2025-08-05 15:58:29
1
alexei :
you’re a kid?
2025-08-06 22:28:11
2
d7kette :
Speak on it…cause what actually exists in certainty outside of our own perception….
2025-08-06 09:16:02
1
ssameuel :
A life isn’t to be valued less just because it isn’t percieved
2025-08-14 13:15:13
14
Sam :
yeah i hate when people oversimplify this concept because they’ve heard it in pop culture (despite not understanding it)
2025-08-10 03:42:39
0
To see more videos from user @ategekamusinguzi, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.
