Philipatas
Region: CH
Tuesday 19 August 2025 20:00:14 GMT
290715
17146
580
1867
Music
Download
Comments
Iyasu_MM :
Marx was not a Marxist ? Christ was not a Christian either
2025-08-20 11:10:00
450
Ilko :
She did not say anything about Marxism. She resorted to personal attack.
2025-08-21 11:48:01
48
chefan :
lol. Marx private life has nothing to do with the validity of Marxism. Marx being a drunk doesn't make Dialectical Materialism any less true. In fact you can tell she ain't a Marxist because she uses emotional idealism to criticize Marxism. lol
2025-08-21 01:24:59
326
Em :
"I was married to a Fascist and I was married to a Marxist and neither one of them ever took out the garbage."
2025-08-21 04:03:36
555
mulimwanza :
as much as I agree with Nawal El Sadawi my question is was she married? if she was how did she treat her husband? and if she was a divorcee what cause
2025-08-24 05:10:11
1
Clifford Nyirenda :
Isn't that a fallacy? she's not a Marxist because Marx wasn't a perfect human being
2025-08-20 13:02:44
82
🇵🇪Benjamin T🇨🇦 :
who is this diva?
2025-08-21 12:30:39
161
corporatepariah :
So people are Marxists because they’ve never read Marx? I find that hard to believe. Note, she doesn’t actually highlight any philosophical issues - she just rambles on about religion and then Marx’s private life.
2025-08-20 10:47:43
247
Liza. :
What’s this woman’s name, she seems interesting
2025-08-20 17:27:08
178
wordsoundmix :
So this is why I've been seeing her in the media... Non-marxist critic, the only one alowed in the western discourse. Btw she didn't name any particular criticism about Marx's ideas, only some vague accusations about his private life...
2025-08-20 13:57:07
64
Ngqozobhi :
She studied Marx instead of Marxism. She even did a paternity test for the child that claimed to be Marx's child.
2025-08-22 05:00:37
8
Lawrence Waigwa :
How Marxism Relates to the Current Generation 1. Inequality & Wealth Gap Billionaires and corporations control huge wealth while most young people struggle with unemployment, student loans, or low-paying jobs. Marxism explains this as the natural outcome of capitalism where the rich (bourgeoisie) exploit the working class (proletariat). 2. Gig Economy & Job Insecurity Many youths work on short-term contracts, freelancing apps, or delivery platforms with little stability. Marxists argue this is “modern exploitation,” where workers don’t own what they produce and are easily disposable. 3. Climate Crisis Capitalism values profit over sustainability, leading to overproduction, pollution, and global warming. Marxism highlights how endless pursuit of profit destroys both people and the planet. 4. Global South vs. Global North Developing countries often provide cheap labor and raw materials for wealthy nations. Marxists call this neo-colonialism, showing how capitalism continues global exploitation. 5. Youth Activism From climate protests (e.g., Fridays for Future) to labor union organizing, many young people are reviving Marxist-inspired ideas without always calling them “Marxism.” Social justice, feminism, anti-racism, and equality movements often echo Marxist thought about power and oppression.
2025-08-20 10:31:04
5
Bra Mphoza :
I love listening to this woman she's insightful .... Nawal El saadawi
2025-08-22 18:18:05
18
Albanian Steve :
All the people complaining about this point have obviously never seen a group of first year uni students who act like they’re better than everyone else because they were gullible enough to get convinced to join their local Marxist club lol
2025-08-21 05:14:02
24
Mr.Flex :
How can one study religion
2025-08-20 11:53:31
2
M :
ironically, her reasoning also applies to her
2025-08-20 15:09:02
98
Katejo13 🇨🇦 :
I love her and feel the exact same way. You have to practice what you preach, otherwise it means nothing.
2025-08-24 20:26:31
9
Fe :
Frantz fanon was a raging homophobic and misogynist but I still agree with much of his work. I may not like someone bc they’re a terrible person but that doesn’t negate that some of the things they say might have actual value. Anywho his misogyny and contributions to Marxist theory are not mutually exclusive , he could be both misogynistic and still have written valuable things about Marxism. But I can see why she’s hostile towards him. I’m like this way towards conservative Christianity lol.
2025-08-22 15:20:19
4
Irodotos Iosif :
so a smoker doctor can not tell u that smoking is harmful for ur health,
2025-08-20 17:30:50
21
October enjoyer 🔻 :
plot twist, she never read Marx
2025-08-21 04:35:10
19
... :
Critiquing Marx’s personal life is fair, but reducing him to that alone isn't. As Marxists, we recognize he was flawed and a product of his time. But Marxism isn't his private property, it's a tool that helps us understand and change the world, his flaws don't erase its value. Dialectical and historical materialism allow us to trace the economic foundations of patriarchy and expose how women’s unpaid labor is exploited under capitalism, Marxism is a tool uniquely useful to the feminist movement. Marxism helps us understand the oppressive nature of the economic and social systems we live under. Also, if her critique is that Marx himself wasn’t a Marxist, then she’s basically admitting that Marxism is better than Marx. So why reject Marxism for Marx’s flaws
2025-08-24 16:33:15
4
Willy Marin :
Ok, I get giving a hard stare down to Marx from the perspective of feminism. Engels, despite not being in the name, is a fundamental pillar to marxism, as much as Marx himself (I’m sure she knows this since she read marxism, right?). How does she account for Engels super progressive stance on women and critique of the patriarchal family or even his life long relation to Lizzie Burns?
2025-08-21 07:52:27
5
Learn 2 Discern :
Marxism fails because it fails to account for the human condition.
2025-08-21 05:35:25
0
To see more videos from user @philipatas, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.
