Victoria Aveyard
Region: US
Friday 26 September 2025 12:00:05 GMT
79025
5305
661
405
Music
Download
Comments
Elena May 🧚♀️ :
Senlinyu is a talented enough writer to practically build an entire world that completely separates itself from HP in Alchemised in my opinion
2025-09-26 14:13:46
1050
Alyssa Berry📚 :
So have you credited, compensated and gotten consent from J.R.R. Tolkien for realm breaker????
2025-09-30 15:02:05
300
hancan67 :
So Ali hazelwood should pay George Lucas for the love hypothesis?
2025-09-26 15:53:32
711
columbula :
Are you gonna give the Tolkien estate compensation for Realm Breaker?
2025-09-27 03:04:40
253
Deanna DeCenzo :
Disagree. Work of art inspired by fan fiction that easily stands on its own. Mortal instruments is nothing like Harry Potter. Alchemised truly is entirely new. It’s not similar to hp
2025-09-26 13:33:18
967
𝘊 ♡ :
Weren’t you a fanfic writer tho?
2025-09-30 17:23:55
210
🪷Moriah🦋📚 :
Nooope, lost me here 😬
2025-10-22 13:10:26
0
Sarah :
And yet powerless is a rip off of your work😭
2025-09-26 12:17:23
218
Elisabeth G. Mark - Author :
First time I disagree with you on something. Most of the FFs I’ve read who got published were already so far removed from the original content. This is not like you do your own Star Wars Merch and have to pay royalties.
2025-09-26 13:08:26
584
Kt_san :
Technically, any book that markets itself by referring to popular works like acotar, lotr, etc is leveraging their bases and yet most book blurbs do so. I think a lot of work (fanfic or published) is derivative and most stories told are different takes on classic stories which are often spins on folklore and so forth. We don’t live in a vacuum.
2025-10-30 05:18:21
0
Ash✨Wren :
are you going to pay the Tolkien estate for realm breaker?
2025-09-27 15:08:14
76
Sina || Booktok 📚 :
So Star Wars needs to pay the Dune creators? Girl no? If you’re referring to Alchemised, it was nothing like HP. they did it perfectly as an own standing world.
2025-10-19 07:00:19
149
katelyn :
Totally disagree. Copyright laws are already in place for this exact reason. This would completely rework derivatives and stifle people from actually creating works. Every piece of fiction is based off of something else, no one has completely new ideas. We have infringement laws already in place to prevent what you’re speaking of. The framework is already there to protect “poorly refurbished works.”
2025-09-26 18:23:18
339
Louisa | Author :
I don't agree, and perhaps your feelings come from what has happened with the Powerless series (understandably so). I think if I wrote a popular book, someone wrote a fanfiction based in the world and then they went and and recrafted their own writing, into a new world of their own, I'd be rooting for them. I wouldn't want compensation. If I've inspired someone to pursue their own passion then that honestly enough. But I appreciate not everyone feels this way, but I don't know what everyone is so afraid off.
2025-09-26 12:30:06
573
IgnoringReality :
If you can go in blind and read a book like Alchemised for example, not knowing its origins and not being able to link it back to hp for example, there’s no reason compensation needs to happen. They worked hard to rework that and make it original
2025-09-26 15:09:50
605
Interrobang :
I’m an IP litigator. There’s such a clear body of law governing this. Copyright doesn’t protect ideas. I get your points regarding the “moral” right thing, and there’s some merit to them. But legally, the law is already clear.
2025-09-26 20:01:31
325
Bosnian American Kitchen :
If manacled had never been fan fiction first, we would never have known that Alchemised derived from it.
2025-09-27 00:11:35
116
Time to roll the dice :
Genuine question: did you go through these steps before publishing Realm Breaker? You mentioned that it was a fanfic based on LOTR
2025-09-26 18:06:10
30
caitlinslibrary everywhere :
For the people confused: based on/fanfic ≠ inspired by
2025-09-26 18:29:49
32
Allie Davies :
Ya know, I fully get your perspective, especially considering the things that get said about your work and works that came after. THAT SAID, I feel so strongly that all fiction is derivative in some way at this point, and so then the lines of what kind of source work requires these 3 C’s comes into play. Because when you’re actively divorcing a story from the source world, how far divorced does it have to become to no longer be more derivative than a story that has roots in Arthurian legends? Obviously when something starts as a well known ff, the roots of the story are known, and it’s easier to point to. But what if the same story had been inspired by a world, started as a private story sketched into an existing world and then was moved into an original one for trad publishing? Idk 🤷🏽♀
2025-10-13 04:57:38
2
Jordan Lopez | emerging author :
I fear people in the comments don’t understand the difference between being inspired by someone’s work and using someone else’s work to build a story off of.
2025-09-26 15:22:38
199
Victoria 📚👻🥀🗡️ :
Since you did get your start in fan fiction I am curious if you did the three c’s back then? Or is this more of a nuanced view now due to booktok blowing up books these days. This is a genuine question as a newer fan (waiting for war storm from Libby and absolutely love the series)
2025-09-27 03:53:11
4
jordan | literarypolitic :
The comments do not pass the vibe check I fear, trad published fanfiction is weird imo
2025-09-26 22:54:33
4
To see more videos from user @victoriaaveyard, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.
