None of us are confused. The writer is just wrong. Plain and simple lol
2025-10-03 13:43:27
1290
Brandon Reyes :
there’s no water, it just means that style has fluid motions. Theres no thunder, it just means that style is fast and direct. the “effects” are just representations of how different swordsmen fight
2025-10-03 09:23:29
3874
Manly Battleships :
Jojo's Bizarre Adventure has entered the chat
2025-10-07 15:25:32
0
kazo_arcane :
it's not conjuring water or fire. it's literally evoking water or fire. except for genya. that's real.
2025-10-03 01:25:56
4126
John Goddi :
Knowing that actually makes the anime much less interesting
2025-10-03 16:47:03
223
gutterspeak :
i thought it was fully a visual metaphor for the audience, not the people in-universe.
2025-10-03 04:21:48
416
Luckii :
The flames from zenitsu using lightning flame god whatever burnt his cloak. They physically are real. Tanjiro literally created rain when he killed ruis mom with blessed rain after the storm.
2025-10-04 20:35:35
0
JoeCollins :
That's a lot of words to say it's an illusion
2025-10-03 03:29:04
5464
Jus kith🙏🙏 :
Im pretty sure its just meant to really show that they’re not superhuman or mutant they’re just at the highest point a normal human can reach
2025-10-09 13:50:23
0
Void :
zenitsu literally flys tho
2025-10-04 22:11:22
6
JotaroMyBeloved :
Like stands in JoJo.
2025-10-03 00:22:17
71
sdfl.kal :
the writer should have just said the effects were illusions, he makes no sense
2025-10-04 05:16:07
1
Jojo :
obanai’s breathing style encapsulates this perfectly. he’s not summoning a snake he’s mimicking a snakes movements
2025-10-03 19:12:25
679
ran :
i always thought the characters dont
actually see it like how in martial arts sometimes they say like this the tiger or whatever technique
2025-10-03 01:11:20
487
Millie :
The breathing effects are just a visual aid so that readers and watchers can visualize the actual stroke of a blade technique. that's what I've always read them as anyway.
2025-10-03 17:14:39
284
Ayla🏳️⚧️ :
The Zenitsu scene in the movie kinda proves the creator wrong. The lightning caused a bunch of damage as it traveled upward before he even moved. It just doesn't make sense
2025-10-03 16:19:48
4
Tyler :
"Not real" But Tanjiro heard Thunder when Zenitsu used Thunder breathing back in Rui's mountain 💀. Why did the mangaka have to say this 😭
2025-10-03 14:58:39
57
kiskisbella :
The joke is “I understand that the water and fire are drawn in for the audience to see the movement of the swords/characters/readability, but it looks so cool, so I’m ignoring it” people know they aren’t there, but acting like they are is fun. It’s essentially the rule of cool overriding real world logic
2025-10-03 00:33:52
353
abrattowers :
I understand what you’re trying to say, but in a world where demons have special blood arts with crazy effects that affect the environment around them, what does it cost the artist just to say/admit/confirm/accept that breathing affects are real? Like no gang..
2025-10-05 02:34:27
5
Isaactp123 :
the new movie kinda proves that the effects arent there murata uses water wheel and there is no effects, and it doesnt make sense to say hes using a rlly weak version
2025-10-04 08:06:28
0
skooter :
i interpreted it more as like… they’re so skilled at their respective breathing styles that it looks like said effect. like being slashed by water breathing just FEELS like being slashed by water so the fluid motions cause it to look like water too… if that makes sense. muichiro probably gets a mist effect by moving his clothes, immense speed, and throwing up the dust on the ground when he moves. which causes the mist effect people talk about. sanemi probably moves his sword so fast that it causes an immense amount of wind to surround him which creates the vortex effect. although demon slayer is very inconsistent when it comes to this because Zenitsu burns his clothes after using thunder breathing in the movie so… and how would people even see love and sound breathing… 😭
2025-10-03 02:52:08
97
Aiden Caron :
after I saw zenitsus kimono catch fire with his breathing from i threw what the author said out the window… they are real for me and that’s all that matters 🙏🏻
2025-10-03 23:54:13
198
James Pachucki :
So then explain muichiro connuring mist during the swordsmith village arc when he’s fighting the vase guy
2025-10-04 10:19:59
1
Loneheart :
N..no?
That's not what's happening at all.
2025-10-05 00:34:04
0
Get_Dunked_on :
They aren't real, YET THEY DO STUFF THAT CAN ONLY BE EXPLAINED BY BEING REAL
2025-10-03 18:58:01
2
To see more videos from user @schemingbanshee, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.