lola yang ☯︎ | pre-med 🩵🥮🩺
Region: US
Tuesday 04 November 2025 14:20:15 GMT
146748
7422
1094
632
Music
Download
Comments
daslappdon :
Is your teacher on a list?
2025-11-04 21:41:07
3531
Fredo_585 :
Incestuous relationships can be associated with abuse, grooming or other unhealthy power dynamics hard to see from outside the family. Even if this hypothetical doesn't have that, a general taboo is still desirable for that reason
2025-11-04 16:38:55
2361
peeekosuave :
YES ITS WRONG
2025-11-07 06:26:06
0
Netters300 :
Their business is not my business …. END 🫡
2025-11-07 06:12:38
0
Beepbopboop :
I like questions like these. In my ethics class we discussed cannablism. And the morality and cultural aspects of it. It’s wrong to kill someone and eat them, but is it wrong to eat them if they naturally died? Does it make a difference if you are doing it to survive? There are cultures that have been known to eat people once they have past. Do we define an entire culture as wrong? Or is it okay if it has cultural/ religious significance?
2025-11-06 03:02:02
3
Fey :
As long as two consenting adults engage in behavior that doesn’t harm others or violate rights, it’s not my place to judge. Ethically, it’s permissible, though personally, I find it quite…icky
2025-11-05 21:17:33
795
stateofgerb :
rly scary how many people in these comments can’t engage in an academic hypothetical thought experiment about ethics meant to teach students to think through things that feel wrong inherently and investigate why
2025-11-05 05:21:58
1459
TheGardenCat :
I feel like the professor has an agenda💀
2025-11-06 09:57:19
0
Mary C :
It is wrong. There will always be a power dynamic. One of the siblings had to pursue the other and possible change or manipulate their view of “sibling love.” It would be rare/impossible for both siblings to go against such a strong and well established social norm in the us.
2025-11-04 17:13:33
676
loganprichard522 :
"If we removed any and all consequences from an immoral action is is still immoral" 🤔🤔🤔🤔
2025-11-06 23:17:53
7
Kayla Noel Neece :
Let’s use Kants universal maxim. If EVERYONE did this, would it be okay?
2025-11-04 20:07:14
165
valencia.apryl :
Morally I think it’s wrong bc I don’t belive it’s only wrong if they have kids, I think it’s wrong mentally bc they are siblings so yes that bothers me even being adopted they still have a view of being siblings so they should both know it is wrong, it’s also got to have mental side effects like most things in life
2025-11-06 17:57:29
0
Kaya :
I’m calling the police
2025-11-04 21:12:01
547
truthbesaid25 :
Yes it is because we can not normalize that! Period!!!
2025-11-04 18:48:22
73
Lys :
You guys aren’t fully understanding her question, at the core she’s asking this to get an answer that considers the societal meaning we as humans have imposed onto such a practice, exclusionary of the scientific findings that have developed over time and influenced our perspective. That is at the heart of ethics
2025-11-05 17:00:06
272
J.K. Spivey :
So to answer this thought experiment we'd have to look at another thought experiment called “Transgession Progression” in which transgressions committed within a two or more person system creates a safety net for the system but also opens the system up to more transgression in the future, like stealing, murder, and other forms of socially taboo ideals. Since they're already high up on the transgression progression table, they will either freefall through all of the other lower transgressions by default or escalate due to the addictive nature of committing “sins” together. Therefore it is both immoral and unethical for them to engage in the act or continue, because they are opening themselves up to a system of addiction toward the taboo that can only spiral and harm others or their mental health. It also prevents them from having healthy attachments within the social constructs and familial ties.
2025-11-06 16:19:01
0
Tootie :
After reading these comments I'm realizing that being philosophical doesn't come naturally to everyone. XD
2025-11-05 04:39:13
737
Abby :
These comments don’t get it!!! My professor did the same exercise
2025-11-05 11:00:25
16
saška ❤️🔥🌙 :
I think it’s wrong because the only siblings that have a romantic relationship are those that have been abused. Therefore naturally you would not look at your sibling and want to have a relationship with them.
2025-11-06 06:00:27
1
Anna :
Wrong unless Targaryen
2025-11-06 05:59:41
4
360Noahscope :
I’m seeing women in the comments talking about calling the cops or asking if the teacher is on a list, like, you DO know what “ethics class” entails… right?
2025-11-06 16:50:25
9
Lonna bonna :
Why was this a question…..? I’m huh?
2025-11-04 17:36:11
177
PP :
Yeah, God says so
2025-11-05 04:14:04
3
Lo Wils :
What in the sigmund Freud is going on…..
2025-11-04 23:55:20
190
The Top Chode :
perfectly ethical if there is 0% risk
2025-11-05 19:27:17
9
To see more videos from user @postgradpremed, please go to the Tikwm
homepage.
