@mattstormcrow: My main critique about the play loop of Dungeons and Dragons. #dnd #dungeonsanddragons #ttrpg #dndtiktok

Matt Stormcrow
Matt Stormcrow
Open In TikTok:
Region: US
Thursday 16 October 2025 18:53:42 GMT
7876
1206
93
200

Music

Download

Comments

radiofreewill
Radio Free Will :
Co-signed. Fully.
2025-10-16 18:58:44
25
basicsofthegame
Jeremiah McCoy :
Everything you have just can truthfully be said about almost every game. I have seen people be equally disengaged with Vampire, GURP's, Call of Cthulhu and dozens of games. I have had to coach players in World of Darkness, Star Trek, Star Wars ect. It is dishonest to say D&D is unique about it, but hey, rage bait drives traffic, right?
2025-10-16 23:53:57
11
ttrpg_dude
TTRPG_Dude :
I dont disagree, but I think it also needs to be said that there are types of GMs who prefer that, who want all of the control, want there players to rely on them
2025-10-28 22:09:22
0
smellman1995
Smell :
This is why PF2e is my preferred fantasy TTRPG. The players NEED to work together against challenges the GMs make rather than just "Cast Fireball, Win Encounter." I find myself so much more engaged as a player in that game.
2025-10-17 07:04:12
16
myster..z
Dizi :
This is one of the many reasons I think of 5e as the McDonald's of TTRPGs
2025-10-16 19:03:25
73
adagio240
Adagio :
what's easier to run than 5E?
2025-10-17 04:03:56
0
makancheesy
Makancheesey :
So 5e is bad if you play it wrong. If you made this same argument with any game, it'd still be right. So if it applies to everything, then it applies to nothing
2025-10-17 04:37:54
1
renleyrenfield
renleyrenfield :
Dungeons & Dragons is a war game that sometimes people talk over. It's not a role-playing game. because of all the combat that people talk about, one might as well call Monopoly a role-playing game so long as you talk in character :p
2025-10-16 18:57:45
4
kythegm
KytheGM :
I never considered this perspective and yet now I realize I’ve been living it for over a decade 😅 so glad you pointed it out!
2025-10-16 18:59:03
20
shades_corvid
Shades Corvid 🍉 :
DM are much easier to get to try a different sys then DnD only players.
2025-10-17 08:14:38
2
biscuit_powder
Cookie :
I agree 💯%. How guilty of this would you say WoD games are?
2025-10-30 10:03:29
0
armorfrogentertainment
ArmorFrog Entertainment YT🟥 :
the number of times I've asked a player "what's your spell save/maneuver DC?" and the player doesn't know. 😒
2025-10-17 10:05:20
11
metamored
Metamore 🇺🇦 :
wish there will be subtitles in video 😥
2025-10-16 19:55:10
0
geek_the_gm
geek the gm 🍉 :
You my friend have found a wonderfully insightful critique of D&D
2025-10-16 20:30:58
17
seanvanooteghem
Sean VanOoteghem :
The most fun I’ve had in playing ttrpg’s for 30 years has been Ultraviolet Grasslands and the Black City. It’s EXTREMELY simple, not only for the players but also for the DM. It does the best job I’ve ever experienced encouraging interaction from everyone evenly. And that’s because the system (included in first edition and expanded into Our Golden Age, which is free) is very simple but the game already has the bones/framework for everything. From the world and it’s non-canon history that is created with the players at the beginning, quickly, to every possible location, NPC and monster (either premade or simply generated on the spot), everything is ready to go and the story that is told is completely unique every time. The character’s story and exploration are the only factors that haven’t been premade and it forces everyone to engage with those points because of it. If you haven’t played UVG than you’re missing out.
2025-10-17 12:17:02
0
yourbrinypal
yourbrinypal :
This is why I will die on the hill that not only are there better games at being both about Dungeons and/or Dragons, but that those games are often better at being games too. I don’t think I’ve ever sat at a table that actually fully engaged with the D&D rules.
2025-10-16 20:48:02
13
wileinercabrita
Josman Espinoza :
I mean it's an easy game but that's not necessarily a bad thing, the lack of engagement come from many places and I'm sorry but you don't really need to know the lore to play VtM.. the DMs have the same responsibility in all of those games to play the games, they're all just different types of games
2025-10-16 20:21:33
1
mayitbetree
love :
people expect critical role level campaigns but they dont do critical role level playing and it drives me mad.
2025-10-17 08:14:34
16
tim74312
TimQuestionMark :
It’s Ttrpg lite. It should be a gateway to better games and not the end state.
2025-10-17 00:00:33
5
antsy97
Antsy97 :
Choose violence today did we?
2025-10-16 21:27:02
0
nopenopenope1945
Old Tony :
Nothing you have said is specific to any one gaming system. You can have lazy, bad players in VtM just like in 5e. You can have permissive DMs who allow themselves to take on these rules/gaming burdens in any system. There are less crunchy and more crunchy systems out there…none of that matters if your group just wants to show up, throw dice, kill stuff and be entirely uninvolved with the lore or your plot. Here’s a take: if you’re dm’ing this type of group and it was clear in your session zero what your expectations are, then find new players.
2025-10-16 23:19:26
0
ravenqtrnm
mystraven :
eh this is partly on DM's for not requiring there players to engage with their characters or know their character abilities. as a dm i dont hand hold unless you're a new player and even then I make the players learn their class. if you dont hand hold those unengaged pc will die which is fine dont be afraid to of pc death.
2025-10-17 02:26:36
0
ulf359
HeathenFraud :
Thank you, I’ve been trying to find the words for why I dislike D&D and why it’s so hard to shift D20 players away from it. This makes near perfect sense now.
2025-10-17 00:16:08
0
shadowrunnerd
ShadowrunNerd :
I never thought of it like that but I see your point. I branched out if D&D with Shadowrun and despite the reputation of being really crunchy and complex I found it was actually less stressful and I think it’s because it actually asked less from me and allowed me to spread some of the work onto the players.
2025-10-17 00:43:48
0
zangari581
zangari581 :
Shadow of the Demon Lord is even easier
2025-10-17 01:12:58
0
To see more videos from user @mattstormcrow, please go to the Tikwm homepage.

Other Videos


About